Never Let Me GoTeaching and learning resources for the novel Never Let Me Go By Kazuo Ishiguro
Among dystopian science fiction novels, Never Let Me Go is unique in its nonconformity to the standard patterns of the genre. It tells its haunting story about the moral hazards of technological advances by focusing on the lives and relationships of children at a boarding school as they grow up together. It’s one of my favorite books, and I spent quite some time combing through it for material to include in the study questions presented here. My notes are an attempt to articulate some of the important themes, issues, and symbols to help students process this rich, complex work.
The film based on the novel was well-received by critics and expertly captures the novel’s characters and tone.
I’ve also linked two articles that may be of interest in teaching or studying the novel: an interview with Ishiguro around the time of its publication that gives some insights into the book and his approach to writing, and a 2017 New York Times article about Ishiguro’s career after the announcement that he had won the Nobel Prize in Literature.
“Never Let Me Go“
(song from the movie on YouTube)
Myths and Metaphors (Atlantic interview)
Note: The page numbers given in some questions may differ from other editions of the book.
Part 1, Chapters 1-5
1. Pay special attention to the opening pages. What tone and mood do they establish for the novel? Discuss what you think they reveal about how the story is being told, why, and for what audience.
2. Describe Tommy. Find examples of things he says and does in these chapters to support your characterization of him. Why do you think he has tantrums? How does he change over the course of these first few chapters? What indications are there that he has feelings for Kathy?
3. Describe Ruth. Find examples of things she says and does in these chapters to support your characterization of her. Discuss the nature of her relationships with others. Why do you think she acts the way she does?
4. Describe Kathy, and discuss her relationships with Ruth and Tommy. Find examples of things she says and does in these chapters to support your characterization of her. Why do you think she remains close and loyal to Ruth, and what does this loyalty reveal about Kathy? What indications are there that she has feelings for Tommy?
5. What qualities make Kathy an effective narrator? What external evidence is there in these chapters to support your claims? Why do you think Ishiguro chose to narrate the story through a character like Kathy? (How does her personality influence the way the story is told? How do her audience and her perspective on the story relate to the manner in which she reveals crucial bits of information about the setting and the background of the story?) How is a flashback approach to telling the story effective and appropriate?
6. Discuss the immediate setting of this part of the story. What is Hailsham like? Describe the lives of the students at Hailsham—in what ways are their lives different from those of typical children?
7. Discuss the background of the story. What is revealed in these chapters about the “outside world” and the background of the characters’ lives? What mysteries are they confronted with?
8. What conclusion do Kathy and Ruth and their friends reach about Madame’s feelings toward them? Why do you think Madame feels this way?
9. What do you think is the psychological and thematic significance of the “secret guards” and the fantasy of the plot against Miss Geraldine?
Chapters 1-5 Review
10. What things in these first few chapters do you think have symbolic significance? Discuss your interpretation of them.
Part 1, Chapters 6-9
1. What do you think Norfolk might be symbolic of?
2. What is the emotional and thematic significance of the song “Never Let Me Go”? Why do you think Ishiguro chose to use this as the title of the novel?
3. What do you think is the meaning of Madame’s reaction to seeing Kathy singing the song and clutching her pillow? Why do you think Miss Lucy is so disturbed by the children’s pretending to be electrocuted? What do you think is the meaning of the scene in which Kathy witnesses Miss Lucy furiously blacking out the students’ writing?
4. How is the use of skeletons to teach lessons about sex symbolically and thematically appropriate?
5. What is the psychological significance of the jokes about donors’ “unzipping” themselves to make donations?
Chapters 6-9 Review
6. What events cause Tommy and Kathy (and to a lesser extent the other children) to begin thinking about the circumstances of their lives as “donors” and questioning the significance of certain aspects of life at Hailsham? What is Tommy’s explanation of Miss Lucy’s comment that they have been “told and not told” about their lives, and what does this say about human nature?
7. Find examples of foreshadowing in these chapters and discuss their narrative significance.
8. What further evidence of Kathy’s integrity and reliability as a narrator is there in these chapters?
9. How is Kathy and Tommy’s relationship further developed in these chapters? Why does Kathy have such a strong reaction to Tommy’s feigning happiness (p. 106)? In their subsequent conversation, why do you think that she avoids his gaze, and what is the significance of the silences between them?
10. What further information do these chapters contain about the clones and their lives as donors?
11. What unusual and even unnatural aspects of life at Hailsham are presented in these chapters?
Part 2, Chapters 10-13
1. What do you think is the purpose/significance of the essays the Hailsham students have been asked to write? What is Kathy’s current attitude toward her unfinished essay? Why do you think she sometimes considers writing it?
2. How are the Cottages a symbolically appropriate setting for the story? (Think of their original use.) What is Keffers’s attitude toward the students? Why do you think he acts this way?
3. What role does television play in the lives of the people at the Cottages?
4. What signs of increasing maturity are there among those at the Cottages—in what ways are they more “adult”?
5. What are “the two Ruths”? What insight does Kathy have into the reasons for Ruth’s behavior, and how does this affect her attitude and behavior toward Ruth?
6. What complexities and paradoxes in Keffers’s attitude toward the students are shown in this chapter? How might Keffers play a symbolic role in the novel? How might his initial treatment of Ruth’s collection be symbolic?
7. What do you think Kathy’s motive in looking through the porn magazines might be?
8. What taboo is there about the students who have already left the Cottages, and how does this reflect the general attitude of those at the Cottages toward the future?
9. What further information do we find out in this chapter about the nature of those who are future donors? Why are they fascinated by the topic of their “possibles”? Discuss the psychological effect you think it would have on people in their situation to know that the people they were cloned from might be living normal lives somewhere.
10. What is Ruth’s “dream future,” and how is it appropriate for her? What psychological role do these dream futures play in these clones’ lives?
11. Discuss Ruth’s behavior in this chapter. Describe some instances of her rudeness, and discuss Kathy’s reaction to Ruth’s behavior. How does she respond to Chrissie and Rodney’s question about Hailsham students, and why do you think she acts this way?
Part 2, Chapters 14-17
1. What is Ruth’s bitter response to her disappointment regarding her “possible”? Why does Kathy have such a strong reaction to Ruth’s words?
2. What does Kathy and Tommy’s experience in Norfolk suggest about the symbolic meaning of both the Judy Bridgewater tape and Norfolk? Why doesn’t she want to tell Ruth about the tape?
3. What is Tommy’s theory about the Gallery, and how does this affect him? What apparent support is there for his theory? What is ironic about his statement that “none of us are in any particular hurry”?
4. What do you think happened to Kathy’s tape? What evidence can you find in the text?
5. What more is revealed about Kathy’s interest in the porn magazines?
6. How might Tommy’s animals be symbolically significant? What unfathomable reason do you think Kathy has for being reluctant to praise his drawings?
7. Why do you think Ruth pretends to forget things about Hailsham? How does she get revenge on Kathy for finding the tape with Tommy and not telling her about it? Why do you think Kathy is unable to respond to this? Why do you think Tommy looks at her “like [she] was a rare butterfly he’d come across on a fence-post”?
8. What factors pull the Hailsham students at the Cottages apart?
9. Why do you think Ruth tells Kathy that Tommy would never be interested in her? What effect does this event apparently have on Kathy, and why?
Chapters 14-17 Review
10. What foreshadowing regarding Kathy and Tommy occurs in these chapters?
11. Why do you think the students choose to become carers rather than remain at the Cottages for as long as possible?
Part 3, Chapters 18-20
1. In what ways is Kathy well suited to work as a carer?
2. Why do you think Kathy is initially reluctant to talk with Laura? How is their conversation further validation of Kathy’s reliability as a narrator?
3. Why does Hailsham’s closing concern Kathy so much? Why do you think the continued existence and operation of Hailsham up to this point has been so reasurring to her? What symbolizes its closing in Kathy’s mind, and how is it an appropriate symbol?
4. Why do you think Kathy decides to become Ruth’s carer? What event precipitates this decision, and what theme is her decision an example of? Why do you think she decides to become Ruth’s carer before becoming Tommy’s?
5. Why do you think the carers and donors are so interested in the stranded boat?
6. How might the appearance and history of Kingsfield be symbolically significant? What is ironic about its name?
7. Discuss the symbolic significance of the stranded fishing boat and the marshes. What evidence can you find in the text to support your interpretation? What reaction do they have to it, and why do you think they have this reaction?
8. Based on Ruth’s comments about Chrissie and her later comments about being ready to be a donor, what contradictory impulses do the clones seem to have about their lives? How would you explain this contradiction?
9. Why do you think Ruth gets a look of triumph on her face after Kathy mentions Madame? How are her subsequent words surprising? Why do you think she makes this suggestion and gives Kathy and Tommy this gift?
10. What does Ruth’s behavior in this chapter show about how she’s changed since Kathy last saw her? Why do you think she has changed?
11. What feeling haunts Kathy and Tommy’s relationship, and how is it manifested? Why do you think they have this feeling? How do they deal with it?
Chapters 18-20 Review
12. What do these chapters reveal about the techniques are employed to make the clones accept their status and society’s exploitation of them? Consider, for example, the phenomenon of “carer fatigue,” the common refrain of “It’s what we’re supposed to be doing, after all,” the use of the term “completing,” and the splitting up of former friends.
Part 3, Chapters 21-23
1. This chapter contains very complex symbolism that makes many details of the chapter that might otherwise seem random or arbitrary take on a greater meaning. Although this symbolism is certainly open to different interpretations, let’s assume that Madame and Miss Emily’s house represents the mind of society in terms of its attitude toward the clones. If that is the case, what might the following details of this chapter symbolize? As you ponder this question, keep in mind what qualities are typically associated with darkness, the Victorian period, owls (and, conversely, fire), etc.
- the darkness of the house (249)
- the colored glass at the entrance (249)
- the narrowness of the halls/sense of being cramped (249)
- the Victorian furniture (249)
- the picture of an owl-like bird in place of the fireplace (250)
- the barely-visible watercolor painting of Hailsham—lit by a lamp that has “a crooked shade covered with cobweb traces” (250)
- the different levels of the house
- the sliding doors at the rear of the sitting room (250)
- Miss Emily’s frail, contorted, disabled state (255)
- the cabinet’s being taken away (257)
2. Discuss the differences in Madame’s and Miss Emily’s attitudes, personalities, and philosophies. Consider, for example, their attitudes toward the social movement to give clones better lives, the value of their work, and the persistent rumors of deferrals.
3. Discuss the picture of their society that Miss Emily paints for Kathy and Tommy. What is the justification used for exploiting clones? How did this practice come about—what historical situation gave rise to it? Why do Miss Emily and Madame seem to be convinced that the practice will never end? What connections with the practice of slavery in the United States can you see?
4. What is Madame and Miss Emily’s primary strategy for convincing people to support their cause? What does “soul” mean as the word is used in this chapter? What effect did the Morningdale scandal have, and why?
5. How do Madame and Miss Emily justify their decision to keep Hailsham’s students relatively ignorant about their fate? How do Tommy and Kathy seem to feel about this decision? Why do you think they don’t seem to have a deep sense of gratitude for all of Madame and Miss Emily’s efforts on their behalf?
6. Why does Tommy scream? What insight do he and Kathy have about the screaming fits he had as a child? Discuss the significance of this quote as it relates to the novel: “It seemed like we were holding onto each other because that was the only way to stop us being swept away into the night.”
7. What attitude does Tommy seem to have about his drawings after the trip to Littlehampton? (See also page 275.) Why do you think he feels this way?
8. What signs are there in this chapter of Tommy becoming distant? What do you think are the reasons for this distance and for his decision to change carers?
9. What different ways do the clones have of dealing with fourth donation? What do you think would be the best way to deal with it? What deep fear do they typically have?
10. What is the symbolic significance of the river that Tommy imagines, and what theme does it suggest? What does Tommy reveal about his and Kathy’s feelings for each other? What themes are suggested by their failure to get together until the end of their lives?
11. Why do you think Kathy and Tommy’s last few weeks together are “tranquil” and “[don’t] seem strange”? Why is their parting so emotionally muted? How do they feel about having found out things that Ruth never did? Why do you think Tommy shares a small secret with Kathy as she leaves? What does Kathy rely on to give her solace in this difficult time?
12. Discuss the symbolic significance of the final setting of the novel—the flat, featureless, empty fields where debris is blown by the wind and gets caught in the fence and the trees.
1. Discuss the significance of the title of the novel in relation to its plot, characters, and themes.
2. Interpret the cover of the novel (the version with the photograph of a girl’s face)—look carefully at the details of the photograph. Given the subject matter and style of the novel, how is it appropriate?
3. Now that you’ve read the entire novel, discuss the symbolic significance of the following things:
- the forest behind Hailsham
- the ghost of the girl rumored to haunt the forest
- the pond at Hailsham
- the students’ artwork
- Tommy’s animals
- the song “Never Let Me Go”
- the “Lost Corner”
- the Cottages
- the beached boat
- the sea and the seashore
4. What major themes are expressed in the novel? How are they expressed?
5. In general, why do you think the major characters (Kathy, Tommy, and Ruth) act the way they do? Discuss their differing responses to the common problem they all face.
6. What moral stance does the novel take on the issue of using clones as organ donors? What ideas about human nature does the story convey through this moral stance? Discuss the connection between this issue and any other historical, social, and ethical issues that you can think of—consider, for example, the practice of slavery in the United States.
7. In what ways does the novel express moral outrage about the exploitation of “donors”? Think carefully about elements such as the narrative voice, the style of the novel, the events that occur in the novel, the descriptions of the characters, the themes expressed, and the use of literary devices such as symbols.
8. What observations of/lessons about human nature and human psychology does the novel express? How do the characters (and the people of their society) deal with the various unpleasant realities they face? Consider, for example, the use of euphemistic language in the novel.
9. The novel deals with the issue of the human “soul.” What does this nebulous term really mean, and how does artistic expression relate to this issue? What other human activities and characteristics reveal the “soul”?
10. A number of events in the novel, as well as things said and done by various characters, take on a clearer and greater meaning as the novel progresses. Find a few examples of such events, statements, and actions and discuss the evolution of their significance.
11. Why do you think Ishiguro chose to focus on some of the privileged few clones like those from Hailsham rather than on some of the many less fortunate clones that the novel makes reference to—what effects does this choice have on the nature of the story and on the audience? How is it appropriate as a narrative choice, and how does it reflect the general narrative strategy of the novel? Why do you think the characters have such commonplace names?
12. From Kathy’s point of view, what do you think is/are the purpose(s) of the narrative?
13. Typically, dystopian novels focus less on relationships and more on concrete events and actions. Why do you think Ishiguro chose to include so many “soap opera” details of the characters’ lives?
14. Discuss the style of the narration and its effect on the story. In what ways is it an appropriate and evocative choice?
15. Why do you think Ishiguro chose a contemporary setting (though occurring in an alternate reality) rather than a futuristic one, as the authors of other dystopian novels like Brave New World, 1984, and Fahrenheit 451 did?
16. In what ways could Never Let Me Go be described as a woman’s story? What characteristics does it have that distinguish it from more “masculine” stories like Brave New World, 1984, and Fahrenheit 451?
17. What apparent contradiction is there in Miss Emily and Madame’s actions and feelings (and in those of other characters in the novel)? How might this contradiction be explained?
18. What is your opinion about the disagreement between Miss Lucy and Miss Emily/Madame? Support your position with reasoning. What position do you think Ishiguro appears to advocate in the novel, and how does he express this opinion?
Questions © 2007 C. Brantley Collins, Jr.
Themes, Issues, Motifs, and Symbols in Never Let Me Go
Themes, Issues, Motifs
1. Commentary on human psychology/human nature through the donors:
The behavior of the donors as people who for the most part seem to accept their fates: one could almost say that they are complicit in their own deaths; they don’t do much to question the path that has been laid out for them—very few couples even make much of an effort to get deferrals
Reasons for their failure to fight harder for themselves are deeply rooted in human nature:
1. The fear of death and their willful ignorance in not wanting to confront the facts of their lives
2. Passivity in the face of authority and the group—they are reluctant to go against the course that has been set out for them; they have been indoctrinated to believe that it is “right” for them
3. Depression and sense of futility in the face of what seems to be inevitable: many of them seem ready to die at an unnaturally young age because their sense of its inevitability has been deeply ingrained in them by experience
They take refuge in daydreams and preoccupation with other things and thus avoid having to confront the reality of their situation.
In fact, this reflects universal human responses to death—all of us face death and might die at any time, and we react to that central fact of our existence in much the same way that they do.
2. The paradox of Madame’s behavior; inherent irony in her and Miss Emily’s fight on the donors’ behalf:
Her apparent disgust at the sight of them is more complicated than it first seems to the children: on the one hand, she does seem to see them as different than “regular people”; on the other hand, she is dedicated to fighting for their rights and is clearly moved by them—so part of her “disgust” reflects her sense of horror (and perhaps guilt) at how her society is cruelly exploiting them.
For all of their good intentions and sense of self-righteousness, they have accepted the practice of creating organ donors; what they crusade for is simply improved conditions for the donors, not an end to the practice.
3. The question of “soul”:
What “soul” really means is consciousness, a subjective awareness that feels and experiences—an “inner life”
Things that demonstrate its existence through the richness of an apparent inner life (the artwork reflects many of these things):
– complex reasoning
– emotional attachment
– the capacity for love
– new ideas
– the capacity to question and seek answers
– conflict within oneself
– mental initiative: generating ideas and desires on one’s own as opposed to simply reacting to prompts like an automaton
– dishonesty and manipulative behavior
– goals and sense of the future
– capacity for morality and self-discipline
– a desire for redemption: e.g. Ruth’s desire to right her wrongs at the end of her life
– behavior that indicates self-consciousness: e.g. awareness of others’ perceptions of oneself
– behavior that indicates the continuation of internal impulses in the absence of a controlling environment or awareness of an audience: e.g. Kathy’s “Never Let Me Go” dance, which she performs not knowing that she is being watched
4. How are the author’s narrative choices appropriate and effective?
Kathy’s effectiveness as narrator: objectivity and strong sense of ethics (confirmed by the other characters’ comments and various aspects of the plot); subtle and understated emotions—deep and powerful, but not overwrought (her words are measured and considered, not hasty and crude); the normality and simplicity of her narrative voice reflects the author’s overall narrative strategy
First-person narrative reflects the question of the existence of their souls—the existence of the story itself is eloquent proof of the existence of her soul
Hailsham as the primary setting: demonstrates the normality of their emotional lives and the potential within them to be just like any other children—more poignant and revealing than a glimpse at inhumane conditions would be; also adds to the atmosphere of mystery and suspense
Flashback approach: Kathy has had time to process her thoughts about her life and present them in a carefully considered way that reveals things slowly; the fact that she is telling this as someone who has lost those close to her and is confronting her own death adds to its power
The very sense of normality with which she presents it all, instead of confronting us up front with what to us are shocking truths about her life, emphasizes the horror of what has become completely accepted in her society—How could something so cruel and inhumane be normal?
Use of omission and implication
5. Historical/social/ethical parallels:
Slavery: also justified with the argument that those enslaved were less than human, as well as the unwillingness to sacrifice the easier life slavery provides
The exploitation of the underclass: those who benefit are reluctant or completely unwilling to let go of the benefits they derive, so they avoid facing the fact of the suffering of working class and poor people throughout the world
Animal research/animal agriculture: also justified by some people with the argument that animals do not have “souls”
Elitism and segregation: the notion that different standards are acceptable for different groups of people
The cost of comfort: most things that extend our lives have some kind of ethical, environmental, or social cost, yet we accept these improvements without thinking much about the consequences—our lives now are very different than the lives that humans evolved to live within a natural ecosystem (we and our world aren’t “designed” for the way we live now)
1. Hailsham: symbol of innocence
Loss of innocence parallels destruction of Hailsham—Ruth wants to preserve memories of innocence, so she doesn’t look for it
2. The boat: like Charon’s boat to the Underworld, represents mortality
Dialogue in the scene suggests that the characters are catching a glimpse of their impending deaths, which they are fascinated by but don’t want to confront for too long
Imagery also reflects the motifs of helplessness and loneliness
Like the donors, the boat seems to have been forgotten by society, and its origin is a mystery
Boats and water travel are associated with freedom; thus the beaching of the boat is symbolic of a lack of freedom
3. Lost corner: cast off/abandoned by society, the donors are like the things left there
Reflects the human tendency to want to hold on to things, resist change, avoid death (thus the title is about more than Kathy and Tommy’s relationship and their desire to remain together)
Could be seen as “heaven” in a certain sense: the possibility of continued existence
Imagery in last scene is especially important: donors are like the cast-off things and rubbish she sees
Appropriate that they should search for Ruth’s “possible” in Norfolk
4. Forest behind Hailsham: future realities of which the donor children have a vague awareness
Notes © 2007 C. Brantley Collins, Jr.